|
Post by titangreins on Apr 5, 2012 18:13:24 GMT -5
Have been offered.......McCoy and Kolb for 1.02, Locker, Dem Thomas and J Stew
I also hold the 1.04........my RBs are God awful........waddya think guys???
|
|
|
Post by Jaysports on Apr 5, 2012 18:27:56 GMT -5
I love McCoy, but that is too much for him IMO and it's not even close.
1.2 will fetch a stud RB in a great landing spot (Martin, Miller or Wilson). Stewart is sooooo close to busting out as a top 5, don't give up on him now. DT is going to be beastly with Manning at the helm, top 10-15 WR this year with a top 5 ceiling IMO. Locker is also going to break into the top 12-15 QB's by this time next year while Kolb may not even have a starting job in '13.
|
|
|
Post by zildjian on Apr 5, 2012 18:28:24 GMT -5
I would probably do it. McCoy is sooooo good, and although I love J-Stew, you have to wait at least another year on him to be the guy. And Blackmon will nicely replace Dem Thomas and 1.4 could land you a QB or another RB. Yeah, I'd do it.
|
|
|
Post by gambler on Apr 5, 2012 18:33:58 GMT -5
give me the 1.2, Thomas, Jstew side by a solid margin.
I believe McCoy had his best season as a pro last year and will be trending downward this season. I believe a year from now this trade would be laughed at due to the discrepancy in talent.
|
|
|
Post by titangreins on Apr 5, 2012 18:34:44 GMT -5
OK.....1 for 2 against.......need more opinions plz
|
|
|
Post by houdini on Apr 5, 2012 18:42:45 GMT -5
The 1.02, Locker, Dem Thomas, JStew side by a landslide for me.....
Sure, McCoy is the "best" player in the deal, but the sheer amount of quality upside in those 4 outweigh McCoy easily - imo.
|
|
|
Post by dynastyguru on Apr 5, 2012 18:43:26 GMT -5
OK.....1 for 2 against.......need more opinions plz Pull the trigger on that one, before he pulls the offer. 1.02 and 1.04 can Net you Miller AND Martin add in Jstew and as much as I love McCoy, you cant pass that up...oh yeah and Thomas is top 15 now with Manning. Love this deal for you.
|
|
|
Post by houdini on Apr 5, 2012 18:45:57 GMT -5
OK.....1 for 2 against.......need more opinions plz Pull the trigger on that one, before he pulls the offer. 1.02 and 1.04 can Net you Miller AND Martin add in Jstew and as much as I love McCoy, you cant pass that up...oh yeah and Thomas is top 15 now with Manning. Love this deal for you. I think he already owns JStew/Dem Thomas/1.02 and Locker and was offered McCoy if I read the original post correctly??
|
|
|
Post by Jaysports on Apr 5, 2012 18:46:04 GMT -5
I would probably do it. McCoy is sooooo good, and although I love J-Stew, you have to wait at least another year on him to be the guy. And Blackmon will nicely replace Dem Thomas and 1.4 could land you a QB or another RB. Yeah, I'd do it. I think zildjian has this backwards a bit, the 1.2 isn't on the McCoy side. So, guessing if he had to revote it would be all in favor of the Stew, DT and 1.2 side....
|
|
|
Post by burgandy on Apr 5, 2012 18:48:39 GMT -5
Take it. Its hard to overpay for a guy like McCoy, but unless you are STACKED and don't need anything at all, you should do this deal. When stewy breaks out he will BE McCoy.
|
|
|
Post by titangreins on Apr 5, 2012 19:07:32 GMT -5
Reeling this thing back in....cause even I am confused Have been offered.......McCoy and Kolb for MY 1.02, Locker, Dem Thomas and J Stew Originally thought this was a good deal....but ALOT of future talent to give away
|
|
|
Post by shamrock84 on Apr 5, 2012 19:29:55 GMT -5
I think I'd do the deal. I agree you are overpaying but if you really need RBs that is ok. Overpaying for a guy who is tops at his position is the kind of overpaying I can handle and you can't really get a guy of his caliber without overpaying. You still will fetch a decent RB or WR at 1.04. Demaryius is primed to break out with Manning but JStew is still a year away and 1.02 is not a sure thing. You're getting a sure thing and if you won't compete at RB without him then I make the trade.
|
|
|
Post by houdini on Apr 5, 2012 19:40:30 GMT -5
If I could get the 1.02/JStew/Dem Thomas and Locker for McCoy, I would trade Shady away 7 days a week and twice on Sunday. What we saw from McCoy last season was his ceiling and even if he is lucky enough to get the same workload and repeat those numbers (which I doubt), I'd still much rather have the other 3 players and the 1.02.
|
|
|
Post by Coin Flip on Apr 5, 2012 19:47:44 GMT -5
I like the 1.02 pick side.
|
|
|
Post by stuckinthemiddle on Apr 5, 2012 20:42:54 GMT -5
Just to add to the confusion I will take the McCoy side. Not very often you get a chance to put the number 2 dynasty RB on your roster. Stewart may never be the guy, Demayius is top 20 or 25 WR, and 1.02 is a rookie.
How long have people been saying "This is the year." for JStew? I don't think he's going to be traded. Let somebody else wait on him.
You can find a WR that will put up comparable numbers to DT on the waiver wire or a via cheap trade. See 2011 Jordy Nelson, Victor Cruz, Steve Smith, Laurent Robinson, Nate Washington, etc.
If you like what's taken at 2 trade for him later. Either during this season if he's not making an impact like the other owner thought he would or next season when his production drops you could get him dirt cheap.
I gave a lot for Foster. I won't say overpaid because if the same offer was made to me today I would not accept it.
On a side note, the McCoy owner in one of my leagues said we could revisit trade talks after the NFL draft. Counting down the days.
|
|